Civil society definitions of infrastructure usually focus on how infrastructure improves the effectiveness and impact of frontline organisations through capacity building, networking, and shared voice. However, this definition doesn’t acknowledge the interdependent nature of civil society – the effectiveness of one organisation and the experiences of its beneficiaries are influenced by a range of different interconnected actors in the system.
“Covid-19 has provided many clear examples of effective systemic action, and stark lessons in the consequences of non-systemic thinking. Leaders and decision-makers everywhere are being compelled to think broader and deeper about causation and consequence… Systemic thinking, planning, action and leadership must now be mainstreamed – individually, organisationally, societally, across public, private and charity sectors.”
Seth Reynolds, NPC (10)
“Given that many of the issues civil society seeks to address are complex and require the contribution of many actors over the long term, there is increasing recognition that grant-making needs to change — away from funding short term projects delivered by single organisations, to create the conditions for long term systemic change”
Collaborate (11)
In recent years, many funders have been using a systems change lens to understand the complex and interconnected nature of entrenched social issues. In a systems context, multiple actors must contribute to a process of long-term change. Infrastructure acts as the scaffolding for this – helping to build a shared understanding between different frontline organisations and other stakeholders, working iteratively and experimentally, and encouraging cross-system relationships, collaboration and learning.
A systems approach often involves identifying the mindsets, behaviours, practices and relationships which will help achieve long-term change, rather than simply the services or support contracts.
The pandemic highlighted the complexity and interconnectedness of our systems, and the context of the COVID-19 recovery provides fertile ground for thinking about long-term systems change.
Infrastructure, ecology, or operating system?
Perhaps, ‘infrastructure’ is not the right word at all, to describe the structures and networks which underpin a healthy civil society. Consider the following three metaphors and the language associated with them. How do these concepts apply to civil society?
Infrastructure (12)
‘Infrastructure’ usually brings up imagery of roads and railways, bridges and telephone masts, things which are critical to the supply of our basic needs as a society.
- Long-term fixed assets underpinning our livelihoods and the national economy.
- Essential public investment.
- A feat of engineering, design and organised practice.
- Upfront investment which delivers long-term returns.
- Underappreciated or taken for granted, ‘invisible’ until something goes wrong
Ecology (13)
The connections between living things and the world around them.
- Sowing seeds, pollination, germination and taking root.
- Growth, nourishment and flourishing Biodiversity, mutual dependency, relationships between big and small
- Fragility, conservation and stewardship
- Regeneration and rewilding
Operating Systems
The vital software on an IT system which allow the other applications to run effectively.
- Provides common services for other programs.
- Controls processes, information and data flows ‘Mesh networking’ – when different nodes within the system connect to each other to share resources.’
- ‘Forking the code’ – a term which describes when developers use the code from one program to develop a new or separate piece of software.
Infrastructure for systems change behaviours
Below are examples of systems change behaviours – not every organisation can do these things individually, but they can do collectively, and infrastructure organisations help drive or deliver this collective action. Thinking about systems change behaviours is a way of identifying who already plays an infrastructure role in your system or sector, and where there are gaps to fill.
- Bellman: Sharing news and information.
- Librarian: Archiving knowledge and intelligence.
- Scout: Leading and reconnaissance work.
- Pollinator: Taking ideas from one testbed to another.
- Analyst: Drawing together research and data.
- Conduit: Channelling energy and resources.
- Broker: Connecting and facilitating people and organisations.
- Diplomat: Developing, collecting visions and shared-purpose.
- Futurist: Horizon scanning and predicting.
- Guru: Championing collaborating, mutual trust and respect.
- Polymath: Understanding a range of perspectives and specialism.
- Midwife: Bringing new life and alliances.
- Hostess: Championing inclusivity.
3.1 Systems change at different scales
Systems change takes place at different scales and a systems lens is also applicable at a local level. Although traditional local infrastructure such as VCS (voluntary and community sector) networks have been hit hard by austerity and the loss of statutory support, over the last decade there has been a growing interest from funders in place-based investments which tackle complex issues and enable systems change on a geographical basis. Many of these place-based approaches have identified local infrastructure organisations to lead a partnership consortium, distribute funding or act as an anchor point for the programme, because of the local relationships, convening power and insights they hold.
Case Study
Cornerstone Fund: Funding new partnerships to address inequalities
The Cornerstone Fund provides funding for civil society support organisations in London to become “adaptable, resilient, collaborative, sustainable and driven by communities, with a focus on tackling deep seated structural inequalities to improve outcomes for Londoners.” It funds partnerships, led by civil society infrastructure organisations, to build the capacity of civil society groups, augment the voice of communities, or influence policy and practice. There is an emphasis on building trust through convening, facilitating and connecting.
“The Fund has highlighted the importance of funding activity beyond traditional ‘delivery’ roles such as convening, facilitating, and connecting which are essential for enabling collaborative whole system efforts. The importance of these roles has been reinforced in response to the pandemic, with civil society infrastructure acting as a source of collective intelligence for the sector, distributing essential information and resources, and connecting and convening people and local groups and supporting them to act.”
Collaborate, the fund’s learning partner (14)
The Fund is a collaboration between City Bridge Trust, National Lottery Community Fund, Trust for London, the John Lyons Charity, the Greater London Authority, and London Funders. Learning and experimentation on the part of the funders is a core component alongside the grants.
Like other systems change funds, the Cornerstone Fund’s ambitions are centred on testing and learning from ways of working which may result in systems-level impact:
- Systems change ambition 1: Developing and testing new ways of working (for civil society support organisations) to achieve a thriving civil society for Londoners.
- Systems change ambition 2: Developing a new way of funding to achieve a thriving civil society for Londoners and influencing for the adoption of this practice more widely.
Case Study
Power to Change: Investing in the local conditions for enterprising communities
Power to Change’s mission is to support community businesses to make social and economic impact in their local places. Alongside a number of open grant programmes, Power to Change’s activities has included targeted interventions in specific city regions, to understand and to demonstrate “how community businesses can have a transformational effect on place”. This has involved influencing and shaping the existing organisations who can provide development support, networking and shared advocacy for community businesses, including local government/ combined authorities, voluntary sector and social enterprise bodies, private sector organisations (such as Chambers of Commerce or LEPs) and other funders. Partners do not ‘specialise’ in community businesses, or sometimes even recognise the term to start with, but the goal is to foster an enabling environment in which community businesses can grow and thrive.
One example is the establishment of Kindred in the Liverpool City Region. Kindred is a social investment vehicle owned and led by a community of ‘Socially Trading Organisations’ (STOs) – businesses that trade commercially while delivering social benefits. These include community businesses, community land trusts, CICs and social enterprises, cooperatives and some mission-driven companies and family businesses. Kindred fills a gap in support through a mix of cash grants and loans alongside peer support, specialist expertise and learning, with the aim to strengthen the collective impact of investees. Co-funded by the Liverpool City Region Combined Authority and Power to Change, Kindred is an intervention in the social economy which is aligned with wider city or city-region strategies, embracing different language and alliances to position community businesses within a broader mission and narrative for the region.
Developing local infrastructure partnerships
National funders or commissioners working at a local scale may not have a readily available network of specific providers or networks specialising in the frontline groups which you want to support. This means thinking bigger than your direct beneficiaries or a specific sector and more about who is well-placed to help create the enabling conditions for your target groups to thrive in the locality. Have a think about the questions below.
Who might you work with to:
- Influence new market or commissioning opportunities?
- Gain a seat at the table in local policy discussions?
- Leverage funding and resources from others?
- Generate new knowledge and learning?
- Provide peer networking opportunities?
Also consider:
- What does a critical mass of supportive organisations and opportunities look like?
- Are relationships with one specific actor (such as the local authority) are enough to achieve the impact you want?
- How can you combine and coordinate your local efforts with the reach of your national networks and partners?
- How would you plan for and respond to potential political change or shifts in power?
3.2 Equality in the system
Who do our systems serve, and who do they fail? Using a systems lens prompts us to think beyond what already exists, to look at the gaps in support and the actors who do not benefit from the current infrastructure landscape.
The conventional definition of infrastructure as providing capacity, networks and shared voice means that the organisations who do this most prominently are those which have significant ready-made memberships or more informal groupings and can operate at a certain scale. On the other hand, minority communities and organisations by definition are working with smaller populations.
Case Study
Infrastructure Resilience Fund, Youth Futures Foundation: Reaching into communities through diverse partnerships
The Youth Futures Foundation was established in December 2019 with £90m endowment to improve employment outcomes for young people from marginalised backgrounds. Its Infrastructure Resilience Fund aims to build the resilience and sustainability of organisations who help young people who face intersectional barriers move towards and into work.
The Fund has been cognisant that conventional definitions of infrastructure organisations as ‘membership bodies’ or ‘networks’ means that a lot of smaller organisations that provide employment support aren’t funded. Instead, they stipulate that eligible infrastructure organisations are those with networks, members or collaborations of 20 constituent organisations or more. In order to work with groups outside of their existing reach, they have looked to organisations who don’t specifically work in the youth employment sector, but which support organisations whose work involves young people who face racial and ethnic barriers in the labour market, have experience of the care system, are a young parent or carer, have special educational needs and/or disabilities, have experience of offending, homelessness, exclusion, substance abuse or who have a mental health or long-term health condition.
“In designing our approach to infrastructure funding, we intentionally wanted to build a diverse portfolio of infrastructure grantholders that enabled us to partner with organisations who had the membership and reach into communities that aligned with our mission of decreasing racial inequalities in youth employment. This nationwide coalition of support helps identify ‘what works’ and ignites new ideas to change behaviour and practice.”
Aron Fulton, Youth Futures Fund
The funding is currently supporting 11 organisations including those focused specifically on empowering young people from Black and ethnic minoritised backgrounds, including support for the Traveller Movement to develop a youth employment strategy in response to the increased need to tackle high unemployment rates among Gypsy, Roma and Traveller young people; for the Ubele Initiative to design and deliver a new targeted intervention for organisations supporting young people from Black and ethnic minoritized backgrounds; and for Money4You’s BAMER HUB which provides capacity building support on financial literacy and enterprise skills. Ultimately the Fund wants to support these organisations to stay relevant and useful, generating the space and capacity to make the improvements to their systems and services so they have a better-quality membership offer and can become sustainable on this basis.
Case Study
Emerging Infrastructure Design Lab, TNL Community Fund/ Careful Industries
The Emerging Infrastructure Design Lab is a ten-month programme working with seven small voluntary, community and social organisations to strengthen their networks, adapt to their changing environment, and become more digitally resilient. It is funded by the National Lottery Community Fund and delivered by Careful Industries.
All of the cohort work with or support groups of people who have been historically under-represented in positions of power – including young people, Travellers, disabled artists, young women of colour, and people living in poverty. The programme recognises that these types of organisations may be going through intense periods of growth in response to community need, may be navigating the retreat of other services, and some may be facing challenges of how to define their role in the system or evidencing their impact.
“Sometimes it can feel impossible to prioritise nurturing your own organisation when pursuing the outward mission is urgent and feels all-consuming… The broader context of change makes it an interesting time to think about organisational infrastructure. It means that many of the Lab members have a keen sense of things they want to change, but not the time and space to work methodically through the steps to get there.”
The Design Lab offers them the time and space to reflect on their work, and coaching and expertise in digital skills, user segmentation and user-centred design, content design and distribution, approaches for testing and experimenting, and partnership building amongst other things. Grants of up to £50,000 cover their costs working with the Design Lab and implementing changes in their organisations. The programme also aims to stimulate a conversation around the ways infrastructure can reinvent itself for the digital age, and the resource and support it needs to do so.
The pandemic shone a light on fault lines in the existing infrastructure landscape – who was able to access support in times of crisis, who was served by existing networks and conduits, and who was excluded. The Ubele Initiative convened local, regional and national Black and Minoritised infrastructure organisations to raise concerns that while these organisations do exist, they have been systematically underfunded and underrecognised, and therefore unable to provide Black and Minoritised communities with the links into emergency funding that they needed (15).
Funders have started to recognise the need for fluid definitions of infrastructure, proactively working with new and emerging organisations, many of whom who may not self-define as infrastructure.